Main Content

Lesson 01: Globalization

Global Institutions

There are a number of international organizations that influence world trade, and promote globalization. The best known of these is the UN (United Nations) which was founded after World War II to promote world peace. The following is a list of the various organizations, and accompanying videos.

Note: Once you have studied the current content, please click on the proceeding sphere at the top of the carousel to proceed to the next topic.

UN (United Nation)

The United Nations is an international institution that was established in 1945. Its main focus has been on establishing and maintaining world peace and contributing to humanitarian efforts.

Video #.#, Length: 00:01:07, What is the Value of the UN Transcript

IGOR IVANOV: United Nations, today and tomorrow, as yesterday, it will be unique organization with all states participating in the discussions and in the solution of the main international problems. That's why there will be no other such organization. It will continue to be the unique, and it's necessary to reinforce, to adapt that organization to new realities and to new challenges. And I think that only member states can do it. Nobody can do it alone. It's necessary for the cooperation of all member states, because this is our big family, international family. And as in any family, we need to work together.

WTO (World Trade Organization)

A major international institution is the World Trade Organization (WTO), formerly known as the General Agreement on Tariffs and Trade (GATT). The main function of the World Trade Organization is to regulate trade policies among its members. For 2009, membership in the WTO included 153 members.

Videos

 

Video #.#, Length: 00:09:27, World Trade Organization Transcript

SHANIKA HETTIGE: The WTO, or World Trade Organization, is an international organization established to supervise and liberalize world trade. It defines itself as the only global international organization dealing with the rules of trade between nations and is based in Geneva, Switzerland. WTO was founded in 1995 and is one of the youngest international organizations. Its multilateral trading system is, however, over a half-century old, as the WTO is the successor to the General Agreement on Trades and Tariffs, also known as GATT.

GATT was established in Geneva in 1947 with an agreement regarding quotas and tariffs on merchandise trade, negotiated by 23 countries. It was created with the expectation that it would soon be replaced by a specialized agency of the United Nations, UN, to be called the International Trade Organization, or ITO. Although the ITO never materialized, GATT proved remarkably successful for the next five decades, with approximately 130 members.

By the late 1980s, however, there were calls for a stronger multilateral organization to monitor trade and resolve trade disputes, as GATT was the only major agreement governing international trade. Following the completion of the 1986 to 1994 Uruguay Round of multilateral trade negotiations, the WTO began its operations. Numerous trade agreements and all contracting parties went directly from GATT to WTO. By the early 21st century, the WTO had more than 140 members.

According to the WTO itself, by mid-2008 the organization had 153 members. This includes China, India, the Republic of Korea, the United Kingdom, and the United States of America. There are also approximately 30 observers, which include Iran, Iraq, and the Russian Federation. With exception to the Holy See, also known as the Vatican, all observers must begin accession negotiations within five years of becoming observers. Some notable absentees from the members list are Syria and North Korea.

The goal of WTO is to improve the welfare of the peoples of the member countries. Its main objective is to help trade flow smoothly, freely, fairly, and predictably by administering trade agreements, acting as a forum for trade negotiations, settling trade disputes, reviewing national trade policies, assisting developing countries in trade policy issues through technical assistance and training programs, and coordinating with other international organizations.

The organization's desired outcomes of reaching this objective is assurance. Assurance entails that consumers and producers know that they can enjoy secure supplies and a greater choice of the finished products, components, raw materials, and services that they use. Assurance also allows producers and exporters to know that foreign markets will remain open to them. Aside from assurance, this objective, when achieved, also results in a more prosperous, peaceful, and accountable economic world.

Unlike the World Bank and International Monetary Fund, the WTO is run by its member governments. All major decisions are made by the membership as a whole and are taken by consensus. The highest level of the decision-making body is the Ministerial Conference. This is composed of representatives from all WTO members. They meet every two years. Their most recent gathering was in Geneva from November 30 to December 2 of 2009.

The second level is the General Council. This normally consists of ambassadors and heads of delegations. This council handles the day-to-day work in between the Ministerial Conferences and also meets as the Trade Policy Review Body and the Dispute Settlement Body in order to analyze members' trade policies and settle disputes between members.

The third level consists of the Council for Trade and Goods, also known as the Goods Council; the Council for Trade and Services, or the Services Council; and the Council for Trade-Related Aspects of Intellectual Property Rights, or TRIPS Council. These do just as their names indicate and are responsible for the workings of the WTO agreements dealing with their respective areas of trade.

Finally, there are specialized committees, working groups, and working parties which deal with the individual agreements in other areas such as the environment, trade and development, investment and competition policy, transparency in government procurement, membership and administration, trade facilitation, and regional trade agreements.

When WTO rules impose disciplines on countries' policies, these are, in fact, the outcome of negotiations among WTO members. An appropriate analogy for the WTO's role in policy-making is brought about in a radio show which was very actively suggesting the WTO should do this or do that when one of the hosts said, "WTO is the round table in a meeting. The table, WTO, houses the negotiations and enables leaders to have equal opportunities to discuss and render solutions. But other than that, what do you expect the table to do?"

Therefore, the rules of trade are enforced by the members themselves under agreed procedures. Reaching decisions by consensus among more than 150 members is not an easy task. However, it is beneficial, in that decisions are then more acceptable to all members.

The WTO has been relatively successful in reaching its aim of improving the welfare of the peoples of the member countries. It has been able to achieve its main objective of helping trade flow smoothly, freely, fairly, and predictably, creating assurance. This has therefore resulted in a more prosperous, peaceful, and accountable economic world.

Chart 1, shown, shows the increasing world GDP is linked with even greater growth in international trade. Something to be noted is that traded intermediate goods are accounted in the GDP through value added at each step in the production process. However, in the merchandise trade data, the intermediate goods are counted at full value when exported. This is one reason for the higher fluctuations in trade volumes. Further details can be seen in Chart 2, which shows that exports have often exceeded the GDP, except for a few years, like 2008, which is undoubtedly due to the global crisis and recession.

The WTO has gone through a long and arduous process to create rule-based trade policies. This is illustrated by the WTO's World Tariff Profiles 2009 report of the main tariff parameters of the 153 members. Achieving this level of agreement is no doubt evidence of success of the WTO.

For the WTO, there are also successes and failures regarding trade as a solution to the global crisis, aid for trade, and climate change.

Trade as a solution to the global crisis. The fact that WTO is a longstanding, respected forum is an achievement in itself, which allows an avenue of relief in the face of the global crisis. Director-General Pascal Lamy, in 2009, warned members against sliding down a slippery slope of tit-for-tat protectionist measures. By promoting trade, the countries will be able to rebuild their economies and move on the path to recovery.

Aid for trade. In Peru 2007, Latin American and Caribbean countries collaborated to review measures to strengthen aid flows to the region. By 2007, total aid for trade flows had increased by 20% from this benchmark.

And finally, climate change. Although WTO has attempted to reach a consensus on trading only low greenhouse gas emission products, this has not been successful. As a result, this issue will be discussed in Copenhagen in December 2009 at the United Nations Climate Change Conference. Thank you.

 
Video #.#, Length: 00:09:56, Learn about WTO Transcript

SPEAKER: Global organisations-- World Trade Organisation, or WTO.

Need for formation of WTO. Failure of eighth round of GATT held in Uruguay at Punta del Este in 1986, known as Uruguay Round, gave birth to the new organisation and a legal entity called as World Trade Organisation, or WTO. Once again, India became the founder member of the World Trade Organisation, also.

Now let us see how the WTO is supporting foreign trade. Unlike the United Nations Organisation, or UNO, all members of the World Trade Organisation have equal voting and negotiating rights. It provides a framework for operations, implementation, and administration of multilateral trade agreements.

Objectives of WTO. Though the objectives of World Trade Organisation are similar to GATT, they have wider scope, and the powers to enforce its decisions. The objectives emphasize the creation of a global free trade environment among member countries. The World Trade Organisation enables members to enjoy higher income through growing output levels by sharing trade gains.

The objectives of WTO are-- first, to help to remove or reduce barriers to international trade agreement with the member countries; second, to achieve global economic development through optimum utilisation of world resources; third, to increase market share of developing countries through assistance in their development efforts; fourth, to follow a non-discriminatory policy for all member countries; fifth, to act as dispute settlement machinery, as and when disputes arise between member countries.

Functions of WTO. The WTO, being a legal entity, acts as an advisory as well as regulatory body. It performs several functions in order to control the international trading environment. They are-- first, to guide the member countries in multilateral trade; second, to handle dispute settlement with approval rules and procedures laid down by WTO; third, to scrutinize regularly the national trading policies of member countries; fourth, to implement multilateral trade agreements and legal instruments approved at the Uruguay Round; fifth, to participate in global policy making by seeking help from International Monetary Fund, or IMF, and World Bank, or IBRD, as and when necessary.

WTO provisions related to international trade are now similarly applicable to agriculture, which was brought within the fold of GATT in the Uruguay Round, 1986 to 1993, of multilateral trade negotiations, or MTNs.

The World Trade Organisation's Agreement on Agriculture, AOA. The World Trade Organisation's, or WTO, Agreement on Agriculture, or AOA, was put into practice in 1995 after the Uruguay Round of the General Agreement on Tariffs and Trade, or GATT. The WTO agreement focused on reducing trade barriers and was the first codification of global rules for agricultural trade. Developed-world agricultural subsidies remain the largest point of contention, along with the resulting competitive disadvantage faced by developing countries.

WTO and Indian agriculture. It was expected that WTO would create a free trade environment, but it was not 100% successful. Indian agricultural produce could be exported in much larger quantity because of two reasons-- first, reduced tariffs may reduce prices of farm products, and second, India has low labor cost advantage as compared to many developed countries.

There were two major obstacles in the creation of a free trade area-- first, high subsidies provided by EU, or European Union, and US to their farmers as domestic price support; and second, developed countries also gave direct export subsidies to their farmers. These two obstacles halted free trade environment implementation in a true sense.

Effect of WTO regime at a glance. India was exporting over three times of our agricultural imports during pre-WTO period. India's imports and exports both increased during post-WTO period over pre-WTO period. According to a study by Dr. S. K. Dhage during pre- and post-WTO period, India's imports grew faster than exports due to liberalisation under WTO. The gap between the value of imports and exports is narrowing after the WTO regime started functioning.

The exports of Indian agricultural produce could not grow at expected rates as developed countries were not ready to reduce their subsidies. They were not ready to proceed further in trade negotiations as well. In order to fetch the full advantage of the WTO, Indian farmers must be encouraged to reduce cost of production and increase exportable surplus. India must adopt dynamic policies for further improvement. This may be achieved through an alliance of developing nations which would pressure the developed world to reduce their subsidies.

Application of WTO provisions on agriculture involves many contentious issues and is an area of serious concern for developing countries which are primarily agrarian economies. Moreover, the world, despite growing interdependence and integration, is highly heterogeneous with regard to levels of development. This heterogeneity is very much noticeable when we compare the agricultural sector of developed and developing countries.

To summarize, India is constantly improving in the global trade environment. It has contributed as founder member of GATT, as well as WTO. Failure of GATT gave birth to WTO, as a legal entity, to develop and regulate global free trade environment. Implementation of the WTO regime was unable to bring about drastic changes in Indian agricultural sector, which is the backbone for the Indian economy, but it has surely given a helping hand to develop both Indian agricultural imports and exports in a quantitative manner.

 
Video #.#, Length: 00:04:37, The Truth Behind The WTO By War On Want Transcript

SPEAKER: Dawn rises over the paddy fields of Asia. Farmers start the day early, tending their crops as they have done for centuries, providing food for their families and for sale in local markets. Across Africa, millions of ordinary people prepare to go to work in local businesses, factories and markets. In Latin America, children get ready for school, brushing teeth, washing faces. Yes as all these men and women start their days around the world, one organization is holding talks which could destroy their future, their jobs, and their whole way of life. That organization is the World Trade Organization.

In rural communities across Asia, millions of farmers have been forced to abandon their farms as a result of the free trade policies advocated by the WTO. Countries across Africa have seen their industries made bankrupt by the organization's favored free trade policies, with millions of jobs lost and millions of people thrown into long term poverty. The WTO supports the liberalization of services such as water, health, and education as a key element of free trade.

Yet when multinational water companies took control of public services in Latin America, prices rose so much that the poor could no longer even afford basic water to drink. And in Europe, the WTO has ruled against key public health and environmental policies, such as the ban on importing beef injected with growth hormones, even when the scientific evidence says these bans should stay in place.

The World Trade Organization was born in 1995, at the end of the Uruguay round of international trade talks. Its purpose? To open up markets across the world in the name of free trade, and to decide the punishment of any country which does not abide by its rules. It boasts that it is a democratic organization, based on the principle of one member, one vote. Yet the WTO has never held a vote. Instead, it allows the world's most powerful trading blocks, especially the European Union and USA, to bully poor countries into submission behind closed doors. The weakest are threatened with losing aid, debt relief, or trading opportunities if they don't sign up to World Trade agreements.

So whose interests does the WTO really serve? The organization makes no secret of the fact that it acts primarily in the interest of big business. Many of its key agreements were actually written by corporate lobbyists first, and adopted by governments later. The WTO's agreement on agriculture was drafted by the former vice president of Cargill, the world's largest privately-owned corporation.

The TRIPS Agreement on Intellectual Property Rights was first drafted by pharmaceutical and computing companies before being handed over to governments to sign. And without finance companies such as American Express and Citigroup, the general agreement on trade and services, or GATS, would never have come into existence.

[CHANTING]

CROWD: No, no, WTO! No, no, WTO!

CROWD: No WTO! No WTO!

SPEAKER: But there is a resistance. Across the world, millions of people have taken action against the WTO. Farmers have taken to the streets alongside migrant laborers, factory workers, trade unionists and environmental campaigners to demand an end to the current round of world trade talks. They have one message for the corporations and their governments apologists-- "Our world is not for sale."

And the global movement has won important victories. The WTO was defeated in its recent attempt to expand into new issue areas, which would have opened up even bigger markets to corporate plunder. In the face of popular resistance, the WTO's own conferences collapsed in Seattle in 1999, and in Cancun in 2003.

Join the fight against the WTO and its damaging free trade agenda. Together, we can build a better world.

IMF (International Monetary Fund)

The International Monetary Fund's (IMF) main purpose is to promote economic stability through international funding, including loans to developing countries in order to enhance the opportunity of economic growth within these countries. This bank is a nonprofit organization with the aim of maintaining order within the international monetary systems. More recent activity includes attempts at influencing the production and distribution of critical natural resources. Visit the IMF's website and watch the following video to learn more about this organization.

Video

 

Video #.#, Length: 00:02:41, Earth's Precious Resources Transcript

NARRATOR: Our Earth is rich in natural resources, and some countries are blessed with an abundance of resources to call their own. Oil, copper, gold, natural gas, iron ore, potash. The list of valuable resources is long and covers a diverse array of substances.

But how to best manage those natural resources is something we all need to pay attention to. Whether it is the revenue from the sale of the resources, or the resource itself, we need to do a better job of managing.

Water remains the one natural resource we cannot live without. And water is tied not only to our health but also to industrial and agricultural production. In some regions, there is growing competition for limited water resources among agricultural, industrial, and ordinary household users. In some places, rivers and other bodies of water cross political borders and complicate the effective management of water systems.

In the case of oil, natural gas, and mineral extraction, the revenue generated by the sale of these products continues to be an important driver of economic growth and greater prosperity. If properly managed, the sale of these products can help fund infrastructure projects, sustain economic growth, and even help reduce poverty in developing countries. But the record is mixed.

When measured in terms of overall human development-- which is based on indicators of health, education, and living standards-- countries rich in natural resources rank lower than those with few natural resources. And prices for many natural resources tend to be volatile. For countries that sell natural resource products, this means the revenue they take in from sales can vary significantly from one year to the next. This makes it very difficult to save the profits and invest them.

Innovative economic approaches that help create the appropriate prices and markets for water are a first step toward solving global water problems. And for other natural resources, a sustainable investing tool that links investment and growth can help governments make decisions that avoid the pitfalls of investing resource revenues. Other options include saving a portion of profits in a rainy day fund and using budgetary tools to smooth revenue flows. By taking these first steps towards better management of our resources, we will all benefit in the years ahead.

WB (World Bank)

The World Bank assesses the needs of developing and third-world countries and provides necessary counseling and resources, including loans, in order to increase progress in these countries. The World Bank is not really a "bank" in the common sense of the word. Its support is provided through its many World Bank members.

Videos

  • Global Economy at a Turning Point: World Bank
  • World Bank

 

Video #.#, Length: 00:04:01, What is the World Bank Transcript

JEAN FRANCOIS RISCHARD: The World Bank was created in 1944 before the World War II saga was over. It was created together with the Monetary Fund, the International Monetary Fund, and what was going to be later the WTO, the World Trade Organization. In the case of the bank, its main purpose was to borrow money on the markets-- in those days, Europe more than the US-- and to lend this money for the reconstruction of Europe and of Japan and so forth.

So it was a very bold design for the times. And it did that in the '50s. Mostly it was in the reconstruction business. It financed the reconstruction, for instance, of Toyota in Japan. Or the financing for the reconstruction of the French railway system came from there. Then, in the '60s, that reconstruction was over. It went into developing country business, Lending for hospitals, for highways, for ports, for agriculture in the developing world, starting most in Latin America and then going worldwide.

And it really became the World Bank that is known today under McNamara. When McNamara came from the US government to become a very famous president of the World Bank in the '70s. He made it grow to a much bigger place than it was originally. It originally had less than 1,000 people in Washington, and today it has 12,000 people, roughly. And he got the World Bank into social areas-- into education, into health, into nutrition, into what was called basic needs, integrated rural development, and so forth. And so it became the largest and most-- sort of broadest development institution in the world.

And that it is still today. Even though it's a very much changed world, there is still a lot of that work to be done. It still operates by borrowing money in the markets, usually in bonds; using the money for very long-term loans, which all have to do with some development purpose; and then when the loans get reimbursed by the clients, we repay the bondholders. That's the way the World Bank works.

For the very poor countries, it has a special kitty which is not based on borrowing money. It's based on donated money. It's called the International Development Association Window, or IDA Window. And that leads to very long-term loans without an interest rate, or on grand terms for very poor countries, under roughly $1,000 per person.

So it's an institution that's a sort of bank, in a way. There is a sort of financial function, financing function. But it's also full of people who have a lot of knowledge of what works and doesn't work in education, in road surfacing, in building latrines, in textbook publications for schools, in cataract operations-- you name it. So it's not just a money bank. It's a knowledge bank at the same time.

And lately it has become very active also in big global issues, like global warming, the ozone depletion, the pollution of the sea, and so forth. So it is still mainly in the poverty reduction business and the development business, but it's beginning to become a presence in the global issues business, as well.


Top of page