Main Content
Lesson 03: Legal Aspects of Recruiting, Hiring, and Promotion
L03 Case Study Discussion: Exhibits 1-5
Below are exhibits 1-5 that were used at the hearing.
Exhibit 1
In his opinion, AJ Remington referred to the first group as Cluster 1 (unskilled workers) and the second as Cluster 2 (skilled workers). He used Downtown demographics for his consideration of staff composition at SCAM:
Category |
Downtown |
Metroplex |
State |
USA |
White |
10.54 |
70.1 |
78.38 |
71.71 |
Black |
82.67 |
22.8 |
14.44 |
12.86 |
Asian |
1.12 |
0.2 |
2.58 |
5.30 |
Hispanic |
7.07 |
6.2 |
4.69 |
16.91 |
Exhibit 2
Based on statistics for the Metroplex as applied to staff composition at SCAM, AJ Remington determined that there were shortfalls in diversity levels. In the table below numbers are displayed in the following format: 20/8 -12. The first number reflects application of demographics. The second number (after the backslash) represents actual numbers. The third number means + or – from what staff composition should be.
Category |
White |
Black |
Hispanic |
Asian |
Labor Pool |
20/8 -12 |
07/28 +12 |
2/3 +1 |
0/1 -1 |
Housekeeping |
12/28 -16 |
22/9 +13 |
6/4 -2 |
0/1 -1 |
Food Service |
28/16 -12 |
29/9 +20 |
3/3 |
0/1 -1 |
Exhibit 3
Based on those calculations, AJ Remington concluded that under and overutilization in unskilled categories was as follows:
Category |
Totals |
White |
-40 |
Black |
+45 |
Hispanic |
Even |
Asian |
-3 |
Exhibit 4
AJ Remington’s computations for Cluster 2 – using the same method – resulted in the following:
Category |
White |
Black |
Hispanic |
Asian |
Radiologists |
20/20 |
1/7 -6 |
2/2 |
6/1 +5 |
Psychiatrists |
10/11 -1 |
1/4 -3 |
1/1 |
4/0 +4 |
Surgeons |
28/20 +8 |
1/8 -7 |
1/2 -1 |
3/1 +2 |
Dentists |
8/8 |
1/3 -2 |
1/7 -6 |
2/0 +2 |
Internists |
17/12 |
1/6 -5 |
3/2 +1 |
6/1 +5 |
Exhibit 5
Based on those calculations, AJ Remington concluded that representation in medical specialty categories is as follows:
Category |
Totals |
White |
+19 |
Black |
-23 |
Hispanic |
-6 |
Asian |
+18 |
Click on the next page to see exhibits 6-8.